|
As millions of Americans struggle to shed the
excess weight that threatens their health and
longevity, exciting new research indicates that
the milk-derived compound known as whey may be a
valuable weight-loss aid.
These emerging findings demonstrate that whey
modulates several critical pathways related to
weight management, such as supporting satiety,
improving insulin sensitivity, and optimizing
muscle mass. Moreover, research suggests that
whey may help reduce stress, moderate cortisol,
and support healthy serotonin levels, thus
imparting feelings of well-being. These findings
add to whey’s already well-established benefits,
which include boosting glutathione levels,
facilitating immune function, and aiding in the
fight against cancer.
This multifaceted nutrient may thus help to
improve whole-body wellness by supporting
healthy weight, mood, and biochemistry.
What Is Whey?
The term “whey” actually refers to a complex,
milk-derived substance made up of a combination
of protein, lactose, and minerals, with trace
amounts of fat. Protein is the most abundant
component of whey and includes many smaller
protein subfractions and minor peptides. Each of
these subfractions has unique biological
properties. Modern filtering technology has
improved dramatically in the past decade,
allowing companies to isolate some of whey’s
highly bioactive peptides, such as lactoferrin
and lactoperoxidase, which occur in only minute
amounts in cow’s milk.
Studies indicate that whey may boost
weight-loss efforts via several mechanisms of
action. In this article, we will briefly explore
a few possible pathways by which whey may assist
people seeking to shed pounds and maintain an
optimal body weight.
Hormones and Hunger Signals
Human hunger and appetite are regulated by a
remarkably complex set of overlapping feedback
networks that involve numerous hormonal,
psychological, and physiological influences.
This is currently an intensive area of research,
as major pharmaceutical companies seek a “magic
bullet” weight-loss product to bring to
market.
Scientists looking for solutions to the
obesity epidemic are keenly interested in the
hormone cholecystokinin as a regulator of
appetite. During the digestion of food, the
gastrointestinal tract secretes cholecystokinin,
a small peptide with multiple functions in both
the central and peripheral nervous systems.
Several decades ago, researchers found that
cholecystokinin was largely responsible for the
feeling of fullness or satiety experienced after
a meal, and that it helped partially control
appetite, at least in the short term.
Additional hormones involved in satiety and
appetite include insulin, leptin, glucagon-like
peptide 1, and others. Dietary
factors—particularly the amount and composition
of proteins, fats, and carbohydrates
ingested—determine which hormones are released
and in what amounts.
Whey Influences Food Intake
New studies suggest that whey may uniquely
influence food intake through its effects on
cholecystokinin and other pathways. While many
studies have shown that protein is the most
filling or satiating macronutrient, all proteins
may not be equal in this regard. Two human
studies conducted at the University of Surrey in
England compared the effects of whey and casein
(another milk-based protein) on appetite and
satiety-related hormones, including
cholecystokinin.1
In the first study, participants consumed a
liquid meal containing equivalent amounts of
either whey or casein. Ninety minutes later,
they were allowed to eat freely at a buffet. The
whey group consumed significantly fewer calories
at the buffet than did the casein group.1
In the second study, investigators examined
the effects of the whey and casein beverages on
plasma levels of amino acids and satiety-related
hormones. Compared to the casein drink, the whey
beverage produced a 28% increase in plasma amino
acid concentrations over three hours, along with
60-65% increases in two hormones associated with
satiety, cholecystokinin and glucagon-like
peptide 1. The whey group also reported a
greater sense of fullness and satisfaction than
the casein group. The researchers concluded,
“These results implicate post-absorptive
increases in plasma amino acids together with
both [cholecystokinin and glucagon-like peptide
1] as potential mediators of the increased
satiety response to whey and emphasize the
importance of considering the impact of protein
type on the appetite response to a mixed
meal.”1
Taken together, these two studies indicate
that whey consumption promotes feelings of
satisfaction and fullness that lead to reduced
appetite and decreased food intake. Whey may
thus provide valuable assistance for those
seeking to lose weight by helping to limit their
caloric intake.
Weight Loss and Insulin Sensitivity
High-protein diets have been found to reduce
body weight and increase insulin sensitivity.
Scientists at Australia’s University of Adelaide
sought to determine whether particular types of
dietary protein influence these outcomes.2
In this study in rats, the test subjects
consumed a high-fat diet for nine weeks, and
then switched to a diet containing either
moderate or high amounts of whey or beef protein
for six weeks. The scientists found that high
dietary protein intake reduced energy intake,
possibly due to the satiating effects of protein
as compared to carbohydrates or fats. The
high-protein diets also decreased body fat in
the test subjects.2
Additionally, the whey-fed rats demonstrated
increased insulin sensitivity and a 40%
reduction in plasma insulin concentration
compared to the beef-fed rats. Increased insulin
sensitivity and reduced plasma insulin
concentration are both associated with improved
blood sugar control and reduced fat storage.
Increasing the dietary density with whey protein
also led to reduced body-weight gain.2
According to the researchers, “These findings
support the conclusions that a high-protein diet
reduces energy intake and adiposity, and that
whey protein is more effective than red meat in
reducing body-weight gain and increasing insulin
sensitivity.”2 Whey thus
appears to be an ideal protein source for
promoting healthy blood sugar regulation and
supporting weight loss.
Burning Fat, Building Lean Muscle
Consuming whey before exercise supports fat
burning and may help those who exercise to gain
or maintain lean body mass, according to a study
conducted in Paris, France.3
Scientists have long known that the
composition of a before-workout meal helps
determine what material the body burns as fuel
during exercise. The balance of carbohydrates,
fats, and proteins consumed prior to exercise
may accordingly influence long-term changes in
body weight and composition.
The French scientists studied male rats that
exercised for two hours daily for more than five
weeks. One group of rats exercised in the
fasting state, with no food before exercise.
Three other groups of rats exercised one hour
after consuming a meal enriched with either
glucose, whole-milk protein, or whey
protein.3
The results were quite telling. Compared to
fasting, the glucose meal increased glucose
oxidation and decreased lipid oxidation during
and after exercise. This indicated that the
glucose-fed rats burned sugar over body fat as
an energy source.3
By contrast, the whole-milk protein and whey
meals preserved lipid oxidation and increased
protein oxidation, indicating that fat burning
was maintained and that protein was also used as
a fuel source. The whey meal increased protein
oxidation more than the whole-milk protein meal,
perhaps because whey’s excellent solubility
allowed for its rapid absorption and use as
fuel.3
One of the study’s most interesting findings
relates to body weight, which increased in the
group receiving food and supplements compared to
the fasting group. In the groups that received
either glucose or whole-milk protein, the
increase in weight was from body fat. However,
in the whey-fed group, the weight increase
reflected an increase in muscle mass and a
decrease in body fat.3 Whey thus
appears to be the preferable choice for
supporting improvements in body composition.
The researchers believe that whey’s ability
to rapidly deliver amino acids during exercise
and to preserve fat burning enables it to
enhance the adipose tissue-reducing effects of
exercise training.3 Whey thus offers promise for
those hoping to add muscle mass and lose fat.
Effects on Mood, Cortisol, and
Serotonin
Whey may also support weight loss by
modulating levels of the crucial
neurotransmitter serotonin. Serotonin is
involved in a wide range of psychological and
biological functions, and influences mood,
anxiety, and appetite. Healthy levels of
serotonin are correlated with relaxation, calm,
and an improved ability to cope with stress,
whereas lower levels are associated with
depression, anxiety, and poor appetite
control.
Since serotonin is derived from the dietary
amino acid tryptophan, scientists have
speculated that increasing dietary tryptophan
might increase serotonin levels. A recent study
conducted in the Netherlands examined whether
supplementing the diet with whey-derived
alpha-lactalbumin, a tryptophan-rich whey
constituent, would influence plasma tryptophan
levels, reduce depression, or modulate
concentrations of cortisol, the so-called
“stress hormone.”
The Dutch investigators examined 29 highly
stress-vulnerable subjects and 29 relatively
stress-invulnerable subjects using a
double-blind, placebo-controlled study design.
After consuming a diet enriched with either
whey-derived alpha-lactalbumin or sodium
caseinate, the participants were exposed to
experimental stress. Following the stressor, the
scientists assessed diet-induced changes in
plasma tryptophan and its ratio to other large
neutral amino acids, as well as changes in mood,
pulse rate, and cortisol concentrations.4
In those fed the whey-derived
alpha-lactalbumin diet, the ratio of plasma
tryptophan to other amino acids was 48% higher
than in those on the casein diet. In
stress-vulnerable subjects, this was accompanied
by a decrease in cortisol levels and reduced
feelings of depression. The investigators found
that supplementing stress-vulnerable subjects
with whey-derived alpha-lactalbumin
“improved coping ability, probably
through alterations in brain
serotonin.”4
Synergy with Other Dairy Constituents
Calcium, another component of dairy products,
has been associated with reductions in body
weight and fat mass. Calcium may influence
energy metabolism by helping to regulate lipid
metabolism in fat cells and by modulating
triglyceride storage.5
Several studies have demonstrated that dairy
sources of calcium are superior to non-dairy
sources of calcium for accelerating fat loss and
reducing weight gain. Researchers believe that
the whey fraction of dairy products may be
responsible for this effect, noting that
“dairy sources of calcium markedly
attenuate weight and fat gain and accelerate fat
loss to a greater degree than do supplemental
sources of calcium. This augmented effect of
dairy products relative to supplemental calcium
is likely due to additional bioactive compounds,
including the angiotensin-converting enzyme
inhibitors and the rich concentration of
branched-chain amino acids in whey, which act
synergistically with calcium to attenuate
adiposity.”
Thus, numerous components in whey may act in
synergy to support healthy body
composition.5
Conclusion
Solid research suggests that by supporting
satiety, reducing caloric intake, promoting fat
burning, and boosting lean body mass, whey may
benefit individuals striving to achieve or
maintain a healthy weight. Whey may also support
a healthy response to stress and help maintain
healthy levels of the brain’s
neurotransmitters.
Evidence suggests that consuming whey before
meals may help limit subsequent hunger and food
intake, and that ingesting whey before exercise
may enhance the fat-burning effects of the
workout. Since the effects of whey appear to
last approximately two to three hours, some
nutritional experts suggest staggering whey
intake throughout the day. A healthy breakfast
could include one or two scoops of whey in a
bowl of oatmeal, while a mid-afternoon snack
might be a whey-based shake. Recommendations for
using whey protein as part of a training program
can be found in the e-book, Muscle Building
Nutrition, and other sources of sports nutrition
and bodybuilding information.6
Will Brink writes on health, medical, and
fitness issues. For more information, visit http://www.brinkzone.com/. |